Housing Market Trends: Navigating the Property Dip in 12 States

For prospective homeowners, recent years have been marked by a steady escalation in property prices, making the dream of owning a home seem almost unattainable. However, a fresh analysis by CoreLogic has unveiled a silver lining: 12 states are seeing a downward trajectory in home prices. Here’s a comprehensive exploration of current housing market trends and this evolving scenario.

Housing Market Trends

Setting the Stage

May 2023 provided an interesting data point in real estate. The growth of home prices across the nation exhibited its most sluggish pace in nearly 11 years. This growth was only a marginal 1.4% from the prices seen in May 2022. For eager home buyers who’ve been beleaguered by soaring property prices, this slowdown, juxtaposed with mortgage rates that are teetering around the 7% mark, offers a mix of hope and caution.

The Western Reversal

Western U.S., which became a hotspot for booming real estate prices during the COVID-19 pandemic, is now demonstrating an intriguing reversal. A combination of factors, from the arrival of newcomers looking for affordable housing to being closer to loved ones during uncertain times, initially fueled this boom. States that benefited from this influx are now seeing a pullback:

  1. Idaho: With a significant decline of -8%, it’s evident the boom times are slowing. Notably, cities like Boise experienced a staggering 16% increase in 2020.
  2. Washington: A close second, the state has seen a reduction of -7.5%.
  3. Nevada: The desert state registered a fall of -5.6%.
  4. Montana: At -5.3%, Montana’s housing market is also cooling off.
  5. Utah: The decline here stands at -4.3%.
  6. Arizona: With a dip of -4.2%, the state’s housing market is adjusting.
  7. California: Despite its vastness, the Golden State saw prices drop by -3.5%.
  8. Oregon: A decline of -3.1% has been observed.
  9. Colorado: The state experienced a -2.7% dip.
  10. South Dakota: The decline, although more modest at -1.3%, is still significant.
  11. New York: The Empire State witnessed a -0.3% drop.
  12. District of Columbia: DC’s dip stands at -0.1%.

This list, enlightening as it is, begs the question: What’s driving this trend? According to Kristen D. Conti of Peacock Premier Properties, several factors play a role. The list includes a tightening inventory, changing employment landscapes, the instability in tech stocks, and increased mortgage rates. These elements especially affect markets that have traditionally high valuations.

Furthermore, shifting demographic patterns, exemplified by California’s loss of approximately 343,000 residents in 2022, play a crucial role in influencing these housing market trends.

Balancing Act: Areas Still on the Rise

In contrast, several parts of the U.S. are witnessing unwavering price escalations. These housing market trends have been ongoing for 136 months. Miami, in the Southeast, stands out, boasting an 11.8% year-over-year rise. States like Maine, New Jersey, and Indiana aren’t far behind with appreciation rates of 7.2%, 7.1%, and 6.9% respectively.

What The Future Holds

Relying on their proprietary risk model, CoreLogic has forecasted that certain U.S. areas have a 70% probability of experiencing declining home prices in the upcoming year. Notable mentions include regions in Utah and Florida.

The Larger Puzzle: Inventory Struggles

A recurring challenge remains: the disproportionate balance between supply and demand. Even as mortgage rates see a 1.51% year-over-year spike, the majority of the U.S. is grappling with rising prices owing to sustained demand against a backdrop of limited supply.

The gravity of this supply crunch is further underscored by statistics from a study by Up for Growth. Surprisingly, this shortage is not restricted to coastal regions. Even inland states are feeling the pinch, with Florida, Georgia, and Texas registering significant shortfalls.

Many homeowners, comfortable with their current sub-5% mortgage rates, are hesitating to make a move, further exacerbating the supply challenge.

Wrapping Up

The nuanced shifts in the U.S. housing market trends provide intriguing insights into the delicate interplay between demand, supply, economic variables, and even socio-cultural shifts. While certain states offer a reprieve, the overarching housing crunch remains a concern. For both potential buyers and sellers, staying informed and adaptable is key in this ever-evolving market landscape.

System 2 Thinking (S2T) is a boutique Title Industry Advisory Firm specializing in Title Insurance Licensing, Artificial Intelligence, Mergers and Acquisitions, Compliance Advisory, Process Improvement, and Technology Rollouts. We have been market leaders for over a decade, successfully solving the industry’s toughest challenges while providing unparalleled advisory services. Our partners range from top title agencies, mortgage businesses, and technology startups to Fortune 1000 companies, driving innovation to fuel business acceleration. No matter who you are or your unique challenge, S2T guarantees fast and efficient solutions. Search our comprehensive services today or contact us for a free consultation!

For more information and to talk to a System 2 Thinking expert, please tell us a bit about yourself.